When the Pittsburgh Penguins signed Anthony Mantha to a modest one-year, $2.5 million deal during the offseason, expectations were tempered. He was a low-risk bet — a reclamation project for a player who had shown flashes of dominance but struggled with consistency throughout his career.
As we near the end of the 2025-26 season, that gamble has paid off massively. Mantha is in the midst of a true breakout campaign, producing at a top-six level while playing alongside elite talent like Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin. Not only has he revitalized his own career, but he has also become a key driver behind the Penguins’ push to remain competitive in a tightly contested Eastern Conference.
Mantha’s Career Year Fueled by Opportunity
Through 75 games, Mantha has 30 goals and 58 points — putting him on pace for career highs in both. His 0.77 points-per-game pace is the most efficient of his NHL career and reflects a player who has finally found the right role and environment to succeed.
It’s not just his raw production, but how he’s generating it. Mantha has been deployed in the Penguins’ top six, where he’s consistently skating with Crosby or Malkin at even strength. That alone elevates a player’s offensive ceiling, but Mantha has done more than ride shotgun — he’s been an active contributor in puck battles, offensive zone entries, and finishing plays around the net.
Related: Penguins’ Penalty Killing & Goaltending Issues Remain With Playoffs Approaching
His size (6-foot-5, over 230 pounds) has always been a tool, but this season he’s using it far more effectively. He’s driving the net, creating space for his linemates, and winning physical battles that extend offensive possessions. Combined with his natural scoring touch, it’s made him a difficult matchup for opposing defenses.
Mantha Thriving on the Power Play
Another major factor in Mantha’s resurgence has been his role on the Penguins’ first power-play unit. Playing alongside Crosby and Malkin on the man advantage is a luxury — but it also comes with pressure to produce. Mantha has embraced that role, becoming a reliable net-front presence and secondary shooting option.
His ability to screen goaltenders, retrieve rebounds, and finish plays in tight has added a new dimension to Pittsburgh’s power play. Defenders can no longer solely focus on Crosby’s playmaking or Malkin’s one-timer — Mantha forces teams to account for a legitimate scoring threat in the slot. The result? A more balanced and unpredictable power play that has helped the Penguins convert at key moments throughout the season.
Mantha a Perfect Fit in Pittsburgh’s System
For years, the narrative around Mantha was his inconsistency. There were stretches when he looked like a dominant power forward, followed by long periods of invisibility. In Pittsburgh, that inconsistency has been minimized.
Head coach Dan Muse has put Mantha in a position to succeed by simplifying his role. Rather than asking him to carry a line or create offense on his own, the Penguins have leaned into his strengths — finishing, net-front presence, and complementary scoring.
That structure has allowed Mantha to play a more direct, effective game. He’s not overhandling the puck. He’s not forcing plays. Instead, he’s making quick decisions, getting to scoring areas, and capitalizing on opportunities created by elite teammates. It’s a formula that has unlocked one of the most productive stretches of his career.
Mantha’s Impact on the Penguins’ Success
The Penguins’ season has been defined by their ability to stay relevant in a competitive playoff race, and Mantha has played a significant role in that. Secondary scoring has been a longstanding issue for the team. Opponents could focus on Crosby and Malkin, knowing that depth production behind them was inconsistent at best.
Mantha has helped change that narrative. His presence in the top six gives the Penguins a legitimate third scoring threat, which forces opposing teams to spread their defensive attention. That, in turn, creates more space for Crosby and Malkin to operate — a ripple effect that elevates the entire offense.
Additionally, his physicality and size add an element that Pittsburgh has lacked. In tighter, playoff-style games, having a forward who can win battles along the boards and establish a net-front presence becomes even more valuable. Simply put, Mantha has made the Penguins harder to play against — and that’s a major reason they’ve remained in the postseason conversation.
Mantha Playing for a Payday
With all of this success comes the inevitable question: What does Mantha’s next contract look like? At 31 years old and coming off a career year, he’s positioned himself for a significant raise. A jump from $2.5 million to a $6 million range annually is not out of the question — especially given the rising salary cap and the premium placed on scoring wingers.
Teams across the league are always searching for players who can produce in the top six while also contributing on the power play, and Mantha checks both boxes. The term will be the more interesting factor.
Given his age, teams may hesitate to commit to a long-term deal beyond four or five years. However, if Mantha prioritizes security, he could push for a longer contract in the five- to six-year range, potentially taking him through the remainder of his prime and into the latter stages of his career.
For the Penguins, the decision becomes more complicated. Do they reward Mantha for his breakout season and lock him in as a core piece moving forward? Or do they view this as a peak year and remain cautious about committing long-term dollars?
Penguins Have a Critical Decision Ahead
There’s no doubt that Mantha has earned a raise. The question is whether Pittsburgh is willing — or able — to give it to him.
With significant money already committed to core players like Crosby and Malkin, cap flexibility will be a factor. The Penguins must carefully balance rewarding current performance with maintaining long-term roster flexibility. That said, letting Mantha walk after a season like this would create a massive hole in the top six — one that wouldn’t be easy to fill on the open market.
Looking Ahead
Mantha’s 2025-26 season has been a perfect example of a player finding the right fit at the right time. In Pittsburgh, he’s been given the opportunity, structure, and linemates needed to thrive — and he’s delivered in a big way.
Now, as he approaches free agency, Mantha has turned a prove-it deal into a potentially life-changing contract. Whether that next deal comes from Pittsburgh or elsewhere, one thing is certain: He has re-established himself as a legitimate top-six winger — and he’ll get paid like one.
